Who is credited with writing the earliest play in New York City?

The credit for writing the earliest play in New York City is given to George Farquhar. He is recognized for his contribution to theatre during the early 18th century and is often associated with his play "The Recruiting Officer," which was first performed in 1706 in London but had a notable impact on American theatre as well. Farquhar's works helped establish the framework for comedic plays in the early American theatre landscape, reflecting societal issues and human behavior in an entertaining manner.

The other individuals listed had significant contributions to theatre, but they did not write the earliest plays in New York. Robert Edmond Jones is known for his innovative set designs that advanced the visual aspect of performances. Abe Feder was a prominent figure as an actor and director, and Norman Bel Geddes made his mark as a director and designer, especially associated with futurist designs in theatre. However, none of these figures are credited with the authorship of the foundational plays that shaped New York's theatrical history the way Farquhar is remembered for his early writing contributions.